This is a different Postgame Reactions post.
The most readily apparent thing about this 49ers team is how incredibly inconsistent they are from top to bottom. The first thing I noticed is how easy it seemed for 3rd-stringer Drew Stanton to move the ball against this defense. Yes, the 49ers gradually became more opportunistic as the game dragged on, but it was yet another example of how this team plays up or down to its competition.
The other microcosm of inconsistency was this: Alex Smith play fakes and drifts to his right. Michael Crabtree breaks wide open downfield with no safety help. Imagine seeing a tree uproot itself and walk, and you might understand how rare an occurrence this is. Crabtree does not have game-breaking speed, and Jimmy Raye’s offense does not produce many long balls. I can imagine Smith’s overriding thought: “Don’t screw this up.”
Michael Crabtree and Vernon Davis are both in the top 5 in drops in the NFL right now. So imagine Michael Crabtree, so wide open he’s probably thinking that they’ve crossed into another dimension. He’s a rookie, and he’s probably thinking, “Don’t screw this up.” Remember Josh Morgan with a Shaun Hill pass falling into his arms and dropping it? He said it was like a punt. Smith’s ball to Crabtree was hardly a punt, and yet when Crabtree brings it in, the ball pops out of his hands, and he has to catch it again.
Whatever happened on the play, the route worked, and Crabtree was wide open. The 49ers are not accustomed to plays working the way they’re supposed to. The 49ers of old knew which plays would work, when they would work, and how to execute them. But those teams had a lot of time together. The 49ers of now are starting to figure out what works, they don’t quite know when it’s going to work, and when it does work, they can’t quite execute it just right.
Therefore, sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn’t.
It ain’t sexy football talk, and it’s not going to be a locker room slogan any time soon. I can’t see the 49ers PR department signing off on that going on a billboard. But it is the truth about this team. As for the current PR slogan, “Don’t tell me, Show me,” the 49ers have definitely seemed to stop telling us. But somewhere along the way, they forgot to show us.
Meanwhile, the 49ers won, and it’s still not good enough for people. Alex Smith threw a touchdown pass to Vernon Davis, and even then he’s criticized. Some teams would kill for a touchdown pass, and people whine because Smith didn’t run it in. Last season the 49ers narrowly defeated a Redskins team that was 2-6 in its last eight games, and Hill was hailed for his late-game heroics. Smith finished with a 97.5 rating on Sunday, yet somehow people seem to demand that Smith deliver a 120+ performance.
The 49ers don’t field a team that gives us the right to demand a blowout of anyone, even if it is the Lions. As Mark Purdy of the Mercury News has stated in his most recent column, “the 49ers could get away with being less than perfect.” They couldn’t get away with that this season. The fact that the 49ers won by two touchdowns is a testament to how bad the Lions are. Imperfect and inconsistent teams can still walk out with a win.